Hannah Zulueta is treating at the Pacific Colleges of Health and Science

lets connect

Conditions We TreatWhat Came First, the Tight Shoulders or the Knotted Mind

I have always been caught by the chicken and the egg. Not the riddle itself so much as how often it shows up once you start looking. Which came first runs underneath almost everything, if you let yourself ask it.

A few months ago it showed up in my own back. I noticed my shoulder blades sitting too close together, as if they were trying to touch, with the muscles between them, the rhomboids, pulled tight as a drawn bow. If anatomy is not your language, picture it simply: my shoulders and neck were locked up, the way they get after a long week you cannot quite put down.

I went in for acupuncture. The relief was immediate, the kind you feel walking back to your car. Then, about a week later, the tightness came back and sat right back down where it had been.

At the next visit my acupuncturist did something different. She put me on a herbal formula. That same day, I felt the release, and it had a different quality than the needles alone. What surprised me was what came with it. What I had been calling tight shoulders turned out to be, in part, fluid stuck in my upper body. The muscles let go, and a little water retention let go with them. I had not known to expect that. I had been treating the knot as a muscle problem. It was also a fluid problem.

Here is where it gets interesting, and where the science has quietly caught up to what the needles already assume. We tend to imagine a tight spot as a local thing, one cranky muscle that needs to be pressed. The fascia, the connective web that wraps every muscle and runs through the whole body, tells a different story. Tom Myers spent his career mapping it as continuous lines of pull, which means a tight place between the shoulder blades is rarely an island. It is a node in a much larger web.

And that web is not inert. Robert Schleip, who runs a fascia research group in Germany, has shown that fascia is densely wired with sensory nerve endings and is intimately tied to the autonomic nervous system, the same system that runs the stress response. When those nerve endings are stimulated, sympathetic tone drops and the tissue itself changes, including the quality of the fluid moving through it. The release a good practitioner feels under their hands is not them forcing the tissue apart. It is the nervous system being asked, through the tissue, to stand down.

The fluid part is no longer exotic either. In 2018 a team led by Petros Benias described a fluid-filled space running through the body’s connective tissue, fascia included, draining toward the lymph. It had been missed for a century because the way slides are prepared drains the fluid out and the tissue collapses flat, like the floors of a building with the air let out. We had been looking at a wet, moving tissue and calling it dry. So fluid pooling in the upper back is not a strange idea. It is the architecture doing what architecture does when something upstream stops flowing.

Chinese medicine has assumed this connected, fluid-carrying, feeling tissue for a very long time. It would say the needles moved the stuck qi and asked the nervous system to soften, and the herbs moved the fluid that the softened tissue could finally carry away. The upper body is governed in part by the Lung and the Spleen, the pair that takes in and moves the body’s fluids. When they stall, damp pools where the qi has stopped. Two tools, two jobs, one knot.

But I have not been fully honest yet, and the honesty is the point. There were things in my life during those months that were keeping my mind knotted up. Things I was not saying out loud. So I have to ask the chicken and the egg again. Was it my body knotting my mind, or my mind knotting my body.

This is where both the medicine and the newer science give the same quiet answer, which is that the question dissolves. Schleip describes fascia behaving like a sensory and emotional organ, responsive to our state, which is part of why bodyworkers keep meeting old feelings in tight tissue, and part of why the phrase the body keeps the score landed as hard as it did. In Chinese medicine there was never a wall to begin with. Qi is the same movement that carries the mood and moves the shoulder. The Liver that governs the free flow of feeling is the Liver that governs the free flow through the sinews. When one knots, the other knots, because they were never two separate events.

So I have stopped trying to decide which came first. The shoulders and the worry were the same weather, showing up in two places. The needles spoke to the nervous system, the herbs moved the water, and somewhere in there the thing I had not been saying loosened too. Not because anyone treated my mind. Because, it turns out, there was only ever one knot.


References

Benias, P. C., Wells, R. G., Sackey-Aboagye, B., Klavan, H., Reidy, J., Buonocore, D., Miller, B., Pradhan, D., Carr-Locke, D. A., & Theise, N. D. (2018). Structure and distribution of an unrecognized interstitium in human tissues. Scientific Reports, 8, 4947. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-23062-6

Myers, T. W. (2021). Anatomy trains: Myofascial meridians for manual and movement therapists (4th ed.). Elsevier.

Schleip, R. (2003). Fascial plasticity: A new neurobiological explanation, Part 1. Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies, 7(1), 11–19.

van der Kolk, B. A. (2014). The body keeps the score: Brain, mind, and body in the healing of trauma. Viking.


Hannah Zulueta is a Senior Intern at Pacific College of Health and Science and a Certified Canine Nutritionist dedicated to helping both humans and their companions find ease in their bodies. After a 20-year career in resort hospitality, she returned to school to bridge the gap between metabolic nutrition and TCM principles. When she’s not studying or formulating canine diets, you can find her on the trails.

The articles on this website are personal. They are her stories, observations, and opinions, not medical advice. We live in a time where you can look up almost anything. But access to information and knowing what to do with it are two different things. Her goal is simply to share her perspective, and to think out loud in a way that might be useful to you.

She also understands that acupuncture has an energetic quality to it. Who treats you matters. Her hope is that through her writing, you get a sense of who she is before you ever walk through the door, so that when you do, you’re already halfway there.

Hannah treats on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Fridays at Pacific College of Health and Science. You can request her when you call 619-574-6932.

The information provided here is for educational purposes only. Hannah Zulueta is a future Doctor of Acupuncture, not your doctor. Please consult your physician before making any medical decision

Dedicated to natural health

Sign up for newsletter

Stay connected